Most businesses need both, in a set order. Fix the site first so search engines can crawl it and AI assistants can read who you serve. Then spend on what your buyers actually use. Search still sends far more visits than AI does, but AI answers now shape which businesses make the shortlist.
What should you buy first?
| Your business | Buy first | Then |
|---|---|---|
| Local service, one to three locations | Service and area pages, Google profile, reviews | Answer what customers ask before choosing |
| B2B company with a marketing lead | Pages per buyer type and existing setup | Mentions where buyers read |
| Store with its own catalogue | Product data and structured data | Category guides that compare |
| Already paying an SEO agency | A new brief with a determinant map | Reporting per determinant |
| Wrong AI answers about you | Fix the facts on your own pages | Correct listings and profiles |
What's the difference between SEO and AEO?
SEO gets your pages found and ranked in search engines. The work covers crawling, page speed, titles, content and links.
Answer engine optimization (AEO) gets your business named, and described correctly, when someone asks ChatGPT, Gemini or Google's AI answers who to hire or what to buy.
They overlap more than agencies admit. AI assistants pull some of their sources from search results, so SEO still feeds AEO.1 The difference is in what each one plans around. SEO plans around keywords. AEO plans around the facts a buyer's decision turns on.
Where do buyers actually come from today?
Search sends far more visits, by a long way. Ahrefs tracked referral traffic across 74,752 sites in March 2026. AI chatbots together sent 0.28% of visits and Google sent 28.12%.2 That's Ahrefs' own data.
Share of referral visits, March 2026
But a visit is only part of the story. Fewer searches end in any click at all. In SparkToro's 2024 study with Datos clickstream data, 58.5% of US Google searches and 59.7% of EU searches ended without a click to another site.3 When Google showed an AI summary, Pew found people clicked a regular result in 8% of visits, against 15% without one.4
Visits that included a click on a regular result
So buyers often decide on the results page or inside the chat, then come to you directly. Your analytics show that as direct traffic or a branded search. That's why the AI answer matters even when the AI referral numbers look tiny. My entry on zero-click search has more on this.
What decides whether AI recommends you?
Opascope, an AEO company, coded more than 659,000 ChatGPT answers to buying prompts.1 Here's how often each factor came up.
| Determinant | What it covers | Share of answers |
|---|---|---|
| Use case | The job, what they already run, where | 92.5% |
| Selection criteria | Price, features, quality, support | 83.9% |
| Audience | Role, company size, situation | 59.8% |
| Credibility | Reviews, studies, certifications | 55.6% |
| Brand association | How closely the model links you to the category | 17.1% or more |
Two or more appeared together in 94.4% of answers.1 Opascope notes these shares show how often a factor appears, not how much it weighs.1
When ChatGPT asked the buyer questions first, 88.62% of those questions covered audience, use case, existing setup or selection criteria.1 Almost none asked about reviews or brand, because the model judges those itself. My AEO determinants entry explains how to use this.
The practical upshot is simple. Your pages must say who you serve, which situations you handle, what customers already run, and what they should compare you on. Reviews and mentions on other sites do the rest. The page-level changes are in how to get cited by ChatGPT.
What should you buy if you're a local service business?
Start with the basics that serve both. A fast site with one page per service and per area, a complete Google Business Profile and steady reviews.
Then make each service page answer the questions customers ask before they pick. For a plumber that means emergency or planned work, response time, areas covered and how pricing works. A classic SEO retainer that only writes blog posts for keywords usually misses this.
What should you buy if you're a B2B company?
Buy decision pages before blog volume. B2B buyers ask assistants things like "best agency for a seed-stage SaaS" or "platform that works with our ERP". Those prompts carry company size, stage and existing tools.
So you need pages per buyer type, pages per integration or existing setup, and comparison pages with honest tables. Then earn mentions where your buyers read, such as reviews, industry lists and podcasts. Keep the technical SEO in place, because retrieval still runs through search.1
What should you buy if you run a store?
Start with your product data. Clear product pages, accurate structured data, a clean product feed and visible reviews serve Google Shopping and AI shopping answers alike.
Then write category and guide pages that answer selection criteria, such as size, use, compatibility and price range. Plain keyword copy on category pages helps less than a table that compares what buyers compare.
What if you already pay an SEO agency?
Keep them, and change the brief. Ask for three things on top of the usual work.
- A determinant map for your category, from real buying prompts run in two AI assistants.
- A list of the pages that leave those questions unanswered, and a plan to fix them.
- A report that checks, per determinant, whether AI answers name you and describe you correctly.
If they can only report keyword rankings and traffic, you're paying for half the job. If you're also planning a redesign, read how to redesign without losing traffic first, because a botched move undoes years of SEO.
How do you compare who to hire?
| What to ask | A good answer |
|---|---|
| How do you decide what to write? | From buyer questions and decisions, with a map you can see |
| What do you fix on the site? | Crawling, speed, schema, service and comparison pages |
| What happens off the site? | Reviews, listings, mentions, a plan for each |
| What do you report? | Traffic, leads, and AI answers per determinant |
| Do you guarantee rankings or AI citations? | No. Nobody controls either |
| How long is the contract? | Short first term, clear exit |
Be wary of anyone selling a fixed list of tracked prompts to "rank" for. Buyers rarely type the same prompt twice, so a tracker shows a narrow slice. These are the selection criteria I'd use myself.
Where does Website's Designer fit?
I build and fix the on-site part. That covers structure, schema, decision pages and the facts AI assistants need, through context systems and growth marketing. I work alongside an SEO agency or replace the parts of its retainer that no longer pay. I don't sell link packages or guaranteed rankings.
Questions people ask
Is SEO dead because of AI?
What does AEO stand for?
Answer engine optimization. It's the work of getting your business named and described correctly in AI answers, such as ChatGPT and Google's AI summaries.
Can I do AEO without SEO?
Rarely. If search engines can't crawl and rank your pages, AI tools that retrieve through search are less likely to find them.1
How do I measure AEO?
Run real buying prompts for your category in two assistants. For each determinant, check whether the answer names you, describes you correctly, and which competitor it names instead.
Does AI traffic convert better than search traffic?
Some vendor studies say so, but the volumes are small.2 Judge by leads and sales from both, and by branded searches and direct visits, which AI answers often drive.
