Pick the setup that matches the size of the job, then vet the person, not the pitch. Check two live sites they built, call two recent clients, and get the domain, code and content in your name in writing. Score every candidate on the same ten questions. The one who explains their process best usually builds the best site.
I'm usually the designer being vetted. The difference between a good and a bad hire rarely shows in the portfolio. It shows in the answers to a few plain questions, and in the contract.
This guide covers who to hire, how to check them, and what to sign. It leaves out pricing, because I cover that in what a small business website costs. It also leaves out the platform choice, which has its own WordPress, Webflow, Wix or Shopify comparison.
Should you hire a freelancer, an agency or a studio?
The labels overlap, so here is how I use them. A freelancer is one person. A studio is a small team, often two to ten people, led by the people who do the work. An agency is a larger company with account managers, specialists and a sales team. "Web design company" and "website design company" usually mean an agency.
| Freelancer | Studio | Agency | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Best for | Brochure site, clear scope | Custom site, brand plus build | Large site, many integrations |
| Who you talk to | The person doing the work | The lead designer | An account manager |
| Strength | Direct, flexible, fast decisions | Senior people on your project | Depth, cover for absences |
| Main risk | Single point of failure | Limited capacity at busy times | Juniors do the work you were sold |
| Ask about | Holidays, illness, backup | Who else touches the project | Names of the actual team |
| Check first | Portfolio and references | Process and references | Team and contract |
None of these is better in general. A freelancer who has built fifty sites like yours beats an agency that has built none. The right question is how well the setup fits your job. If your site needs heavy custom development, read web design vs web development first, because you may need two skill sets rather than one.
Who actually builds small business websites?
Agencies do most of it. In a 2025 Clutch survey of 406 US small business owners, 45% said a web design agency built their site. Another 9% used a freelancer or consultant, 37% built it in-house and 9% built it themselves.1 Clutch runs a directory of agencies, so treat this as vendor survey data. The split still matches what I see.
Who built the small business website?
The pool of people you can hire is large. The US Bureau of Labor Statistics counts 220,100 web developer and digital designer jobs in 2025. That splits into 132,700 web and digital interface designers and 87,400 web developers. It expects 5% growth from 2025 to 2035, faster than average.2
US web designer and developer jobs, 2025
BLS also reports that 13% of web and digital interface designers and 18% of web developers are self-employed.2 That's the freelance web designer market. It's a real share of the field, so a freelancer is a normal choice, not a budget compromise.
What should you look for in a designer's portfolio?
Look past the visuals. That sounds odd for a design hire, but there's research behind it.
In a 2002 Stanford Persuasive Technology Lab study run with Consumer WebWatch, 2,684 people compared the credibility of live websites. The look of the site came up in 46.1% of their comments, more than any other factor.3 A companion study asked 15 experts to rate the same kinds of sites. Their comments mentioned design looks far less often. That was 7.6% on health sites and 16.4% on finance sites, against 41.8% and 54.6% for consumers.4
How often credibility comments mention the look of a site
The numbers are old and the web has changed. The lesson holds. Your customers judge your site by its look first, so the look matters. A pretty portfolio, though, tells you little about whether the designer can make a site that works. Experts look at substance, and you should vet like an expert.
So when you open a portfolio, do five things.
- Ask for live URLs. Mockups and Dribbble shots show taste. Live sites show delivery.
- Ask what they did on each one. Strategy, copy, design, build, or only the visuals? Agencies often show work where they did one slice.
- Open each site on your phone. Tap the menu, fill a form, check the text size.
- Check the weight. Run two portfolio sites through the page weight checker. A heavy, slow site in their own portfolio predicts a heavy, slow site for you.
- Look for sites like yours. Same size, same kind of buyer, same platform. A Shopify website designer should show live Shopify stores, with sales flows you can click through.
A great case study names the problem, the approach and a result with a number. If every case study is only screenshots, ask for the story behind one.
How do you check references and reviews?
Call people. Reviews help you build a shortlist, and a phone call tells you the truth.
Online reviews are less reliable than they look. In August 2024 the US Federal Trade Commission finalised a rule that bans fake reviews, including AI-generated ones. It also bans paid reviews that buy a particular sentiment, and undisclosed insider reviews.5 Treat directory badges and star ratings as a starting point.
Ask each candidate for two clients from the past 12 months. Then ask those clients four things.
- Did the project finish on the date and scope you agreed?
- What happened when something went wrong?
- Do you have full access to your domain, hosting and site?
- Would you hire them again for the next site?
The third question catches most problems. A happy client who can't log in to their own site has a problem they haven't found yet.
Who should own the domain, the code and the content?
You should. Make that a condition before any work starts.
The domain. For domains under ICANN rules, the registrant listed in the registration record controls the name. ICANN's advice for changing the registrant is to contact the registrar. A change of registrant details can also trigger a 60-day lock on moving to another registrar.6 If a designer registers your domain in their own name, you depend on their goodwill to get it back. Register it yourself, in your company's name, with your email, and give the designer access.
The code and design. Paying for work doesn't automatically give you the copyright. Under US law, a commissioned work is a "work made for hire" only if it falls into one of nine listed categories and both sides sign a written agreement saying so.7 A website doesn't fit neatly into those categories. The safer route is a written clause that assigns the copyright to you on payment. In the EU, the software directive gives employers the economic rights to programs their employees write. It says nothing about outside contractors.8 So the same logic applies there. Get the assignment in writing, and ask a lawyer to check the wording in your country.
When commissioned work counts as work made for hire
The accounts. Hosting, analytics, the platform account and any paid plugins or fonts should sit in your name. Platforms make this easy. On Shopify, a partner works through a collaborator account that you approve, with only the permissions you choose. Shopify also blocks transferring store ownership to a collaborator.9 That's the right setup. Store, site and data stay yours. The designer gets a key you can take back.
The content. Copy, photos and video you supply stay yours. Ask who owns anything the designer writes or licenses for you, such as stock images or fonts, and whether the licence moves to you.
Your customers' data. If the designer hosts the site or manages forms, they may handle personal data for you. Under the GDPR that makes them a processor. You then need a written contract that covers instructions, security and deletion at the end.10
What should the contract say?
A short, clear contract beats a long, vague one. Before you sign, check that it names these eight things.
- Scope. The pages, features and integrations, listed. Anything missing is extra.
- Milestones and dates. Discovery, design sign-off, build, launch, with dates.
- Revisions. How many rounds per stage, and what counts as a new request.
- Change requests. How changes are priced and approved, in writing.
- Ownership. Domain, accounts and copyright assigned to you on payment.
- Standards. The accessibility level and performance targets the site must meet.
- Handover. Logins, files, documentation and a training session for your team.
- Exit. What happens to work, files and payments if either side ends it early.
On standards, I ask designers to build to WCAG 2.2 level AA. Some businesses also have a legal duty. The European Accessibility Act has applied to e-commerce services in the EU since 28 June 2025.11 Microenterprises providing services are exempt. That means fewer than 10 staff and annual turnover or balance sheet of no more than €2 million.11 A designer who can't say how they test accessibility isn't ready for an online shop.
Payment terms belong in the contract too. For how deposits and budgets usually work, see the small business website cost guide.
What are the red flags when hiring a website designer?
Most bad hires show warning signs early. These are the ones I'd walk away over.
- Guaranteed rankings. Google says no one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google.12 A designer who promises one is either guessing or lying.
- The domain in their name. "It's simpler if I hold it" is a reason to say no.
- No written contract, or a contract with no scope list.
- Unsolicited invoices or pressure to pay today. In 2018 the FTC and its partners announced 24 law enforcement actions against scams aimed at small businesses. One case involved invoices for website design and hosting the businesses never ordered.13
- The pitch team vanishes. If you met a senior designer and a junior you've never heard of turns up after signing, ask why.
- No questions about your business. A designer who quotes before asking about your customers is selling a template.
- Locked-in hosting or a proprietary builder with no export option.
Watch for one softer sign too. Good designers push back. If every idea you suggest is "great", you're buying a pair of hands, and you'll do all the thinking.
Does it matter if the designer is near you?
Less than the search volume suggests. "Website designer near me" is searched often, but most of the work happens on screen. A remote designer with the right portfolio beats a local one without it.
Local still helps in three cases. You want workshops in person. Your buyers are local, and the designer knows the area and its competitors. Or you want a shared time zone for quick calls. If none of those apply, widen the search.
For specialist platforms, start with the platform's own directory. Shopify runs a Partner Directory, so you can find a Shopify website designer without a local search.
How do you use the designer interview scorecard?
Shortlist three candidates. Run the same interview with each, in the same order, and score every row from 1 to 3 straight after the call. Comparing three totals is easier than comparing three good feelings.
Before the calls, write a one-page brief so each candidate answers the same job. The free AI website brief builder gives you one in ten minutes.
| Criterion | Question to ask | A good answer | A weak answer | Score 1 to 3 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Business goal | What should this site do for me in a year? | Names a measurable goal, asks about customers | Talks only about looks and trends | |
| Relevant work | Show me two live sites like mine | Live URLs, explains their exact part | Mockups only, vague about their role | |
| Process | Walk me through the first four weeks | Discovery, sitemap, content plan, dated milestones | "Send your logo and I'll start" | |
| Content and search | Who writes the copy, and how will people find it? | Clear owner, plan for search and AI answers | "SEO is included", or guaranteed rankings | |
| Ownership | Whose name goes on the domain, hosting and code? | Yours, with a written copyright assignment | "Easier if it stays in my account" | |
| Accessibility and speed | Which standard and page weight do you target? | WCAG 2.2 AA, a real number for weight | "It'll be fast and modern" | |
| References | Can I call two clients from this year? | Yes, offers names and numbers | Only testimonials on their own site | |
| Changes and exit | What happens if scope changes, or the project ends early? | Written change process, exit and handover clause | No contract, or verbal promises | |
| After launch | Who updates, backs up and patches the site? | Named plan, response time, training for you | "Just call me" | |
| Team | Who exactly will work on my site? | Names people, says what's subcontracted | Senior pitch, unnamed people deliver |
Scoring. 3 is a clear, specific answer with proof. 2 is a fair answer with no proof. 1 is vague, evasive or wrong. A total of 24 to 30 is strong. 18 to 23 means probe the low rows before you decide. Below 18, keep looking. A 1 on ownership ends the conversation, whatever the total.
Download the printable scorecard (PDF). It has the ten rows above, a reference call script, the eight contract checks and a page to compare three candidates side by side.
What should you do first?
- Register or check your domain. Look up who the registrant is today. If it isn't your company, fix that before you hire anyone.
- Write a one-page brief. Goal, audience, pages, must-have features, deadline. Use the brief builder.
- Decide the setup. Freelancer, studio or agency, using the table above.
- Shortlist three. Check two live sites each and run them through the page weight checker.
- Interview with the scorecard. Same questions, same order, scores written straight after each call.
- Call two references for your top pick. Then read the contract against the eight points above.
If you want me to be one of your three, here's how I work on web design projects. Score me the same way you score everyone else.
Questions people ask
Is a freelancer or an agency better for a small business website?
Neither, in general. A freelancer suits a clear, small scope and gives you direct contact. An agency suits large sites with many integrations. Check the person's relevant work and references either way.
How many website designers should I talk to?
Three is enough. Fewer gives you nothing to compare. More turns into a week of calls, and the answers start to blur.
Who should own my website's domain name?
Your business should. Register it in your company's name with your own email, then give the designer access. The listed registrant controls the domain.
Do I own my website's code once I've paid?
Only if the contract says so. In the US, commissioned work is rarely a work made for hire by default. Ask for a written clause that assigns copyright to you on payment.
What are the biggest red flags in a web design company?
Guaranteed Google rankings, a domain registered in their name, no written contract, pressure to pay at once, and a team that changes after you sign.